Evaluate your suppliers consistently with a scored rating form covering quality, delivery, pricing, communication, and problem resolution. Capture written feedback alongside numeric ratings to build a comprehensive vendor performance record that supports your approved supplier list and ISO compliance requirements.
Free for non-commercial projects, with unlimited forms and responses.
Last updated
A supplier evaluation form brings structure and consistency to one of the most impactful decisions a manufacturing organization makes — who to buy from. Without a repeatable evaluation process, supplier selection and retention decisions are driven by personal relationships, recency bias, and informal opinions. A documented evaluation form creates an objective record that can be compared across evaluators, reviewed over time, and referenced during audits.
This template uses a 1-to-5 rating scale across five performance dimensions that matter most in a manufacturing context: product quality, on-time delivery, pricing competitiveness, responsiveness, and problem resolution. Written fields for strengths and improvement areas give evaluators space to add context that numeric scores alone cannot capture — a supplier might score a 4 on quality but with a note that their documentation quality is poor, which changes how you interpret that rating.
formformform makes it easy to collect evaluations from multiple stakeholders — purchasing, engineering, and production may all interact with the same supplier in different ways. Centralizing their ratings in a shared form gives a more complete picture than any single evaluator can provide, and the submission history becomes a longitudinal vendor scorecard over quarters and years.
Use your own copy to change labels, remove questions and add the details you need. Try the preview alongside this guide to see what respondents will be asked.
Review the starting questions and choices. You can change them in your own copy.
Maria Chen
maria@company.com
e.g. Precision Parts Co.
e.g. CNC-machined aluminum housings
What does this supplier do particularly well?
Where could this supplier improve their performance or service?
Suggested uses, and why this starting point can help. Adapt the questions to your own process.
Replace scattered requests with a consistent starting point. The answers help you understand the work, identify gaps and prepare a follow-up. Review “Evaluation Date” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Replace scattered requests with a consistent starting point. The answers help you understand the work, identify gaps and prepare a follow-up. Review “Product or Service Supplied” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Replace scattered requests with a consistent starting point. The answers help you understand the work, identify gaps and prepare a follow-up. Review “Quality of Products or Services” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Use this as a starting point when you need the same essential information from each person. Review the questions against your process before sharing your copy. Review “On-Time Delivery Performance” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Use this as a starting point when you need the same essential information from each person. Review the questions against your process before sharing your copy. Review “Pricing and Value” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Use this as a starting point when you need the same essential information from each person. Review the questions against your process before sharing your copy. Review “Communication and Responsiveness” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Collect answers in a consistent structure, so you can compare responses while keeping each person’s explanation in context. Review “Problem Resolution and Support” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Replace scattered requests with a consistent starting point. The answers help you understand the work, identify gaps and prepare a follow-up. Review “Supplier Strengths” in particular and adapt it to the detail you need.
Click 'Use this template' to open the pre-built supplier evaluation form in your formformform account.
Customize the rating categories to match your organization's supplier scorecard criteria.
Adjust the overall rating tiers in the dropdown to align with your approved vendor list classifications.
Add a short_text field for the supplier's contact name if you want to track who you deal with.
Set the notification email to your procurement manager and quality lead.
Share the form link with all staff who interact with the supplier — purchasing, quality, production engineering — and ask each to submit an independent evaluation.
perform supplier evaluations at least annually, or quarterly for high-volume or critical suppliers, so the data reflects current performance.
purchasing, quality, and production often experience the same supplier differently. Average multiple perspectives for a fairer score.
on-time delivery should be based on actual delivery records, not impressions. Reference your PO log before submitting.
an evaluation that doesn't lead to a conversation with the supplier, a corrective action request, or a sourcing decision is just a filing exercise.
define what each rating level means (e.g., '4 — Good means less than 2% defect rate') before deploying the form.
ISO 9001 clause 8.4.1 requires evidence that you evaluate and monitor external providers.
Collects quality, delivery, and PPAP documentation performance ratings from commodity managers and plant quality engineers for each annual supplier business review.
Evaluates ingredient suppliers on food safety certifications, allergen control, delivery reliability, and COA documentation completeness for FSMA compliance records.
Rates authorized distributors on counterfeit part prevention, lead time accuracy, packaging quality, and responsiveness to urgent customer orders.
Scores co-packing partners on line efficiency, waste rates, label accuracy, and their ability to accommodate short-notice changeovers or volume spikes.
Evaluates yarn or fabric suppliers on color consistency, weight tolerance, shrinkage performance, and adherence to minimum order quantity commitments.
Documents quality system ratings, regulatory inspection history, and documentation responsiveness for active pharmaceutical ingredient suppliers before approval.
Rates maintenance, repair, and overhaul service providers on turnaround time, technical capability, airworthiness documentation, and repair quality.
Scores building materials suppliers on product specification conformance, delivery scheduling accuracy, driver professionalism, and invoice accuracy.
Evaluates hardware suppliers on product quality, warranty claim handling speed, pricing competitiveness versus spot market, and account manager accessibility.
Rates chemical suppliers on SDS quality, labeling compliance, emergency response availability, and packaging integrity on delivery.
Assesses third-party logistics providers on pick accuracy, damage rates, system integration quality, and responsiveness to claims or discrepancies.
Evaluates tooling suppliers on dimensional accuracy of delivered tools, lead time adherence, engineering change responsiveness, and warranty support quality.
Scores label and packaging print suppliers on color consistency, substrate quality, delivery lead time, and artwork change turnaround.
ISO 9001 clause 8.4.1 requires organizations to evaluate, select, monitor, and re-evaluate external providers. This form creates documented evidence of those evaluations — with evaluator identity, date, scored ratings, and recommendations — satisfying the record-keeping requirement for auditors.
Yes. Share the form link with everyone who interacts with the supplier — purchasing, quality, production — and ask each person to submit their own evaluation. All submissions are stored separately, and you can export them to calculate an average score.
Many organizations share a summary scorecard with suppliers annually as part of their business review process. The areas for improvement field is specifically designed to produce constructive feedback that can be communicated to suppliers to drive performance.
Yes — you can add additional radio or dropdown fields to cover criteria specific to your industry, such as regulatory compliance, financial stability, or environmental certifications.
Export all submissions to CSV from your formformform dashboard. Each row is one evaluation, making it straightforward to sort, filter, and compare supplier scores in a spreadsheet.
Log QC inspections, capture defects, and record pass/fail results by batch.
Report and track production defects with root cause and corrective action fields.
Build an approved vendor list with structured supplier registrations.
Take repair and maintenance requests with category, priority, and access details.
Take service requests with location, urgency, and access details.
Collect a buyer's part specification so a supplier can quote it accurately.
Explore how formformform fits the forms you need to build.
Opens with product context and a link to this page.
Free for non-commercial projects, with unlimited forms and responses.
Use this template